Following regulator approvals in the UK on Monday the 21st of August 2023 and effective approval in the US, Broadcom confirmed that it plans to officially acquire VMware for $61bn on October 30th, 2023.
KCLCA (KCL Conservative Association) are facing criticism for proposing a debate motion entitled ‘this house would restore the British Empire’. Backlash resounded from their direct opposition, with KCL Labour condemning the motion “in it’s entirety” and Liberate KCL staging a protest outside the original venue. The event relocated to UCL – although the location was only disclosed to members via personal invitation, and it was initially hazy as to whether the event had gone ahead at all.
King’s Business Review were able to contact people who were in attendance during the formulation process of this ‘Port and Policy’ event. In an exclusive interview with an anonymous inside source, King’s Business Review have been told that the motion was opposed internally, and initially changed, as only the KCLCA were comfortable with the topic. However, the change was u-turned, as KCLCA members and other members of the committee attempted to reinstate the motion; all while hurling vulgar and sexist abuse, such as “weak b*tch” to quote, at the UCL Tories chair. Members from across other Conservative societies were unhappy with this conduct, with the UCL Tories chair appearing “obviously affected” by the abuse.
Whilst other Conservative societies wanted to scrap the motion altogether, another current senior committee member of the KCLCA wanted to keep but rephrase the motion to something they deemed “less radical”; deciding on “this house believes the British Empire was a force for good”. Subsequently, when the controversial motion was still put forward, UCL, LSE, and UOW Conservative associations “staged a joint walkout against [the motion]”, leaving KCLCA seemingly primarily responsible. Our source claims that other Conservative societies are allowed little to no input in setting the agenda for these debates – “when it comes to port and policy, KCL are almost always the sole organisers”.
The King’s Business Review contacted KCL Labour for a statement, and were quickly told:
“KCL Labour in it’s entirety condemns the Conservative Association’s motion on whether or not to restore the British Empire. Imperialism devastated the lives of millions of peoples – it’s consequences are still felt today and it’s entirely inappropriate to entertain the idea of restoring it. We don’t expect much from the Conservative Association, but we expected better than this.”– Lewis Warner, Co-Chair of KCL Labour
KCL Labour have accepted the statement from the UCL Tories, posting on their Instagram that they “appreciate the solidarity from UCL Tories condemning tonight’s event”. However, they have reaffirmed that they will be “proudly” refusing to collaborate with the KCLCA on any event until they apologise over the motion.
In the pursuit of fair and unbiased reporting, a Politics Editor of the King’s Business Review approached the President of the KCLCA for a statement, but was told that the society is not issuing statements at this time.
Although arguments about the British Empire being a force for good – because of the abolition of slavery, and the banning of the suttee, to name a few examples – do arise, in the modern context the British Empire is commonly viewed as a negative force. AlJazeera identified 50 million excess deaths – explicitly, those outside of the ‘normal mortality’ baseline – as being a direct result of British colonialism in India alone in the 29 years between 1891 and 1920. Economically, colonialism has ensured divides that are still seen in full force today. Indian development, which lags behind it’s Western counterparts despite being one of the fastest growing developing economies, could’ve been “on a par with the developing parts of Western Europe”, if British colonialism had never halted it’s progress. This is only a tiny selection of the impact in India – the British empire also orchestrated the trans-Atlantic slave trade, the opium wars in China, Boer concentration camps, inadequate response to a deadly famine in Ireland that killed millions, and so much more. 65 separate countries have claimed their independence from Great Britain. This article would be dissertation-length if we were to detail every atrocity, every murder, and every detriment associated with the British empire. The legacy of the colonial era runs so deep it is almost immeasurable.
It appears to be agreed that the motion proposed by the KCLCA was wildly inappropriate. With such a diverse and international student body, this kind of topic of conversation is arguably not merely another policy debate. The debate then follows; should university societies, under the platform of a national political party, be able to debate topics such as restoration of the British empire?
On one hand, the go-to argument is preservation of the freedom of speech. However, the lines between freedom of expression and creating an atmosphere of discomfort for other students becomes worryingly blurred. This isn’t just in regards to the recent controversy; the KCLCA have been criticised previously by Roar News for hosting a debate on the proposition of a two-state solution for Israel-Palestine. A select group of attendees dressed in Keffiyeh scarves, presenting themselves as “a caricature of a Middle Eastern terrorist”.
“At this point a member of the audience exclaimed that at least it’s a ‘one to five kill ratio’, referring to the death toll of Israelis versus Palestinians.”– Violetta Fernandez Dieguez, News Editor at Roar News
By only allowing a handful of pre-approved attendees to their events, essentially cherry-picking who can and can’t hear their debates, the KCLCA can attempt to evade differing opinions and challenges. However, perhaps the lesson to learn from this is that if your topics of debate are so controversial you have to switch up venues and pre-approve audience members, you shouldn’t be discussing them at all. If you believed them to be honest, valuable conversations, then you wouldn’t be having them in whispers behind closed doors.
From liberal to post-colonial feminist scholarship, what underpins the logic of restricting religious attire, and why is the world so eager to police the bodies of Muslim women?
Discover how India’s Global Capability Centers have transformed from mere cost centers to innovation powerhouses, reshaping the global business landscape and India’s economic future.
Regardless of which part of the world you grew up in, you probably associate your childhood with the magic and warmth brought by Disney’s cartoons. Although the company has branched out from just animation, it wasn’t always peace and magic in the kingdom of Disney.